Practical Wisdom for Leaders with Scott J. Allen, Ph.D.
The best thinking on leadership, made practical. Practical Wisdom for Leaders turns research into steps you can take this week.
Each episode, host Scott J. Allen, Ph.D., sits down with those who study and practice leadership at the highest level, including Ron Heifetz, Barbara Kellerman, and Jim Kouzes, as well as CEOs, military leaders, and former heads of state. Together, they tackle the problems leaders face every day: the difficult team member, the change nobody wants, the decision with no right answer, and the gap between knowing what to do and actually doing it.
Conversations end with one question: What’s the Practical Wisdom in the discussion we’ve just had?
The official podcast of the International Leadership Association. 350+ episodes. Ranked among the top 2% of podcasts worldwide.
Follow the show so you never miss an episode, and get one practical idea for your week from Scott’s free newsletter at www.scottjallen.net.
Practical Wisdom for Leaders with Scott J. Allen, Ph.D.
Do You Want What It Takes? Scaling with Purpose with Jason Blumer and Ian Vacin
Jason Blumer is an entrepreneur, consultant, and co-author of Scale With Purpose: The Service Entrepreneur’s Guide to Intentional Growth. His work focuses on helping service-based leaders scale their businesses with clarity, intention, and respect for the people who make growth possible.
Jason owned and led Blumer CPAs, a fully virtual CPA firm serving entrepreneurs who want more clarity, confidence, and control as they grow. He served as CEO for more than 23 years. The firm provided full-service accounting departments and tax planning and preparation. Through advisory work, coaching, and onsite consulting, Jason partnered with founders and leadership teams to rethink how their businesses operate, aligning structure, capacity, and culture with long-term goals.
In 2010, he also founded Thriveal, a consultancy and program-based learning organization dedicated to supporting service firm entrepreneurs as they grow, evolve, and build strong, sustainable teams. Thriveal offers monthly mastermind groups that follow its proprietary dashboards for structuring growth, along with coaching and consulting engagements for service entrepreneurs. The organization operates virtually and from its learning center in Greenville, SC.
Ian Vacin is co-founder and chief partnerships officer at Karbon, a maker of AI-driven accounting practice management software, and is co-author of the Amazon best-selling book: Scale with Purpose: The Service Entrepreneur’s Guide to Intentional Growth. He has nearly three decades of leadership experience in technology and accounting with Karbon, Xero, and Intuit, and is passionate about helping accounting professionals be as successful as possible so they can better serve the small businesses they support.
A Few Quotes From This Episode
- "The question is whether you want what growth is going to mean for you, your family, and your identity.”
- “Doing tax returns is way different from running a business that does tax returns.”
- “Sometimes the step back is exactly what you need”
About The International Leadership Association (ILA)
- The ILA was created in 1999 to bring together professionals interested in studying, practicing, and teaching leadership. Attend The Global Conference in Toronto, October 28-31.
About Scott J. Allen
- Website
- Weekly Newsletter: Practical Wisdom for Leaders
My Approach to Hosting
- The views of my guests do not constitute "truth." Nor do they reflect my personal views in some instances. However, they are views to consider, and I hope they help you clarify your perspective. Nothing can replace your reflection, research, and exploration of the topic.
♻️ Please share with others and follow/subscribe to the podcast!
⭐️ Please leave a review on Apple, Spotify, or your platform of choice.
➡️ Follow me on LinkedIn for more on leadership, communication, and tech.
📜 Subscribe to my weekly newsletter featuring four hand-picked articles.
🌎 You can learn more about my work on my Website.
Scott Allen: Thanks for checking in from wherever you are in the world. Welcome to Practical Wisdom for Leaders, the official podcast of the International Leadership Association. I'm your host, Scott J. Allen, and each week I invite executives and scholars to explore the real work of leadership. This podcast is part of a global community committed to helping leaders thrive. If you find these conversations valuable, connect with me on LinkedIn, subscribe to the podcast, and share this episode with others. To learn more about me, visit www.scottjallen.net. And now, here's today's episode.
Okay, everybody. Thank you for checking in wherever you are in the world. Welcome to Practical Wisdom for Leaders. I'm excited for this conversation today. I have Jason Blumer, the coolest CPA I know. Honestly, I'm convinced he's the coolest CPA in the world. And we have Ian Vacin, who is probably the coolest technologist and founder I know. So I know you're going to have a good experience. I'll ask them to introduce themselves in just a moment, but they have written a book, and it's all about scaling on purpose and with purpose. So we're going to jump into that. Jason, tell folks a little bit about you as the coolest CPA in the world, and then we'll jump over to Ian.
Jason Blumer: Well, thank you for saying that, Scott. That's a great introduction. But it's true. I grew up in rock bands. Two years into college with no major declared, everybody said, I think you need to pick something instead of trying to play the bass, since I sucked at that. My dad was an accountant, so I picked that and somehow made it through the CPA exam. Everybody was surprised. I've been running a firm for almost 25 years and a consultancy for 15 years, where we do events and consulting. Scott, you've been involved in Thriveal and have spoken to our group. That's me. This book comes out of all the things Ian and I have learned as we became friends over the past decades.
Scott Allen: That's you. Ian?
Ian Vacin: Yeah, I'm not as cool as Jason. Jason literally does have the cool shoes. I had to get him a Lego set with the shoe because he's that cool. I'm the nerdy guy. I co-founded Karbon about 12 years ago. Before that, I brought Xero to the US and ran that for three and a half years, and before that I was at Intuit for 10 years. Earlier still, I was in semiconductor manufacturing optimization in the fabs, wearing bunny suits and making things go faster. I'm an industrial engineer by trade, and I like to nerd out on stuff. So when Jason and I came together, I was the analytics side of the equation and he was the long-term consultant. Right brain, left brain. It was a lot of fun writing the book with Jason.
Scott Allen: Awesome. Well, okay. So, Scale with Purpose. I was at an event, I think it was last fall, and if I'm not mistaken, you were releasing the book, or we received a copy of it. Just an awesome read. What I would love to know is what you want folks to know about the book. What are two or three things you think are critical for listeners to know? Of course, this podcast has a leadership bent, so anything we can do to veer toward that topic is appreciated. What should listeners know about Scale with Purpose?
Ian Vacin: When we wrote the book, it changed shape over time. Originally it was going to be just a capacity planning book, and then the whole first half became about leadership. After rereading it a million times, the one thing we wanted was to give the reader, the entrepreneurial leader, hope. So we start the book with a quote from Jennifer Green, who was the most vulnerable of the folks we interviewed. She laid out that running these businesses is really hard, and there are points where it becomes crushing. When you're building and running a firm, you don't quite understand all the weight you've taken on. When it becomes really, really hard, you want to do what Jason said in the book, which is throw up your hands and just mow lawns for the rest of your life. We don't want people to do that. The book provides a recipe to understand why it gets difficult, to help those who haven't hit it yet avoid it, and to help the entrepreneurial leader build the business of their dreams based on what they want, not what everyone around them thinks they should build, which is the largest firm on the planet. That's not the goal. So that's the hope. That's what I wanted folks to get out of it. What about you, Jason?
Jason Blumer: Yeah, that's good. Hope was a big part of what we did. I think we also explained why scaling a technical services firm has to be done intentionally. Many technical founders, whether accountants, architects, or engineers, are technicians by trade. When they become entrepreneurs, no one has taught them how to scale a business, so it becomes very accidental. A huge part of the leadership we dove into, and that I work on a lot in consulting and coaching, is that scaling a services business is very human-centric. A lot of the time, we're trying to get people and groups of people to move forward. Scott, that's one of your specialties: helping groups of people move forward at a pace that allows the organization to expand safely. That turns out to be a big change management issue. It has far less to do with technical abilities and a lot to do with leaders who call people to certain places, support them, encourage them, and stay transparent. Those leadership skills are what it takes to get a services company to expand and to do it with purpose and intention. We have a lot of technical how-to in there, but in the first part of the book, Ian, we dove into vision, mission, and purpose, because it's really a leadership book. The back half is pretty nerdy. Ian wrote that stuff. But the front part gets into tons of leadership. That's what I wanted to mention.
Scott Allen: Well, there are some words in there that are really important. Intentionality, for one. To your point, I see it week in and week out. You have an incredible architect, designer, CPA, engineer, technologist, or surgeon, and now they're leading a team. That requires some knowledge, but it also requires intentionality and design. Just like we would design a surgical suite, or, Ian, just like you would design a process to make things go faster, building a high-functioning team and designing culture is a design challenge. That requires intentionality, right?
Ian Vacin: We spent a lot of time talking about not only the design but understanding the scaffolding and the weight of it. We talk about the optimal points as plateaus. You have to put the scaffolding onto the infrastructure of your org design, and that's going to degrade your revenue per employee and your profit. So you have to accelerate quickly to get to the next optimization point for your organization's size, and at that point it has to be redesigned again. If you're doing it intentionally, you can plan a step or two ahead and understand which seats on the bus need to be filled in what order, so the revenue and the resources match and you have a really healthy firm. But most folks say, all right, I just got this big contract, I need a new person. Now you've stacked up five of them really quickly. Oh my goodness, now everyone wants to come to me as the leader with all these one-on-one questions, and I have no time. It just starts to snowball from there.
Scott Allen: That's part of the crushing, right? Part of that feeling of, oof.
Jason Blumer: Yeah, it's a bottleneck. And this stuff is very practical. In Thriveal, we coach a lot of firm owners, and I talk a lot about the ideas in the book now that they're down in writing. Just yesterday we were telling an owner, I think you're at one of those places where you have to reboot. We probably need to remove these people, replace only two of them, and put new roles in place. The book can guide us to that. That's the intentionality. What the owner is feeling is, God, I hate this, I want to go cut grass for a living, which is what I said. Now we have a book that says, no, you're in one of those scaling plateaus. It's on this page of the book, and here's how we're going to address it. Your knowledge and your team structure have only served you up to this point, so we have to dismantle a little of what you have, because a new structure is needed. We started calling that scaffolding in the book. The owners say, yeah, I think that's what's going on. Okay, so let's do it now. And then the hard work starts: have the meeting, let people go, walk it through the managers, set the date. But they have to understand why they're feeling this way and why the firm has slowed down and gotten sludgy. It just hits these walls. So we intentionally push through and do some hard things, we reboot the firm, capacity opens up, and it starts moving forward again. It's pretty rewarding to do that with owners who are really struggling and worried.
Ian Vacin: Jason, I thought you said we were going to write a book about how to cut grass, because it might be fun.
Jason Blumer: That's right. We keep mentioning it. You're driving down the road and you think, I envy that person on that lawnmower. Some days that does look nice.
Scott Allen: Well, now in my neighborhood at least, there are robo mowers. We have a large green area, and the person just sits in their truck drinking lemonade and watching the lawn get cut.
Jason Blumer: See, now that's even better. That's the next book.
Scott Allen: Just get six robo mowers and hang out, right? Something you said really resonated. There's a book, and if the two of you haven't read it, I should put a couple of copies in the mail. It's called The Leadership Pipeline. It's a nice complement to yours. It outlines beautifully: okay, you're managing people for the first time; here's where your focus, time, and energy should go, and here's what you're going to have to let go of. Then if you're managing managers, your time needs to be spent differently again. You'll have to let go of some things and skill up in some areas. Then you're managing an enterprise. The book calls these passages. We have to shed and we have to skill up, and each level requires something a little different. It's normal, it's a pattern, and you can see it. I think you're doing that at an organizational level, and I just love it.
Ian Vacin: Ours is thinner on that. We talk about the fact that you need to delegate and push the work down the organization, because the leader has to free up more time to lead. And we spend quite a bit of time explaining the difference between leaders and managers. It's a very clear distinction, because a lot of folks get in the trap of being a manager even though they have the ownership of the company on their shoulders. You have to make different decisions, hard decisions, and those aren't fun.
Scott Allen: Yeah. And one thing you said that really resonated, Ian: if I'm not flying at the right altitude as a leader or manager and carving out time for the right tasks for that level, we never get to the point where we're thinking two or three steps ahead. We're not carving out what Covey would call the tasks that are important but not urgent. As a result, we're always a little behind, always a little rushed, floating between altitudes and maybe not prioritizing the right things.
Ian Vacin: And you know when you're there because it feels chaotic. It just feels overwhelming. Sorry, Jason, go ahead.
Jason Blumer: It does feel chaotic. What we want the book to do is help you know why. There's a reason, and we often don't know what it is. So there's a lot of intentionality behind saying, this is the pace, this is the time to do this. You mentioned the things we don't do. There's a Peter Drucker idea that we help a lot of managers figure out what to do, but we don't often help them figure out what to stop doing. That's why this book is for technical services organizations: the technical pull is so strong. When technicians move into management or leadership, they have to intentionally let go of the technical skills they spent years building. That's what they feel is valuable, and it is very valuable, but now the company requires something different from them that has nothing to do with technical work. Unless you've got an MBA or leadership training like you have, Scott, most of us don't have much of that. We've been through nerdy accounting and engineering courses, and now we're running a company. We often say doing tax returns is way different from running a business that does tax returns. Those are two completely different things, and technical founders struggle with it. So we have to push them into the role of leadership. We ask, are you the CEO? Why don't you take on that title? They go, ooh. We say, go ahead, claim it. Have you done a vision presentation to your team? They say, what is that? Well, let's build one together, because you need to give it to them by next month. They have no idea what we're talking about. So we push them into those roles, because the skills they need are leadership and management, and they have to start letting go of the technical skills. That shedding feels so weird to them, and I get it.
Ian Vacin: And that's in the book. Julie mentioned it to Jason when she got involved in his businesses: you have to ask the question, do you want what it takes? That's the issue. As the business gets larger, you have to shed the technical work. Let's be clear to everyone in the audience: that's the work you signed up to do. That's the fun work. That's where you want to spend your time as a technician, and it's in conflict with what the business actually needs. When you sign up to be the entrepreneurial leader, that's what you're taking on. As you choose a larger size for your company, you have to do more of the work of running the business. That's the awareness we want to give in the book. Be very thoughtful and intentional about where you want to end up, because that may not be a place that's happy for you. If it's not, stick to a smaller size, where it can feel more like a family business or a lifestyle business than machinery.
Scott Allen: Jason, you've been building for a long time. How do you know when you're in one of those transition points? Is it as simple as, it feels chaotic? Is that an indicator? What signals show up that suggest the system isn't working any longer? I love that quote, one of my favorites: every system is perfectly designed for the results it achieves. How do you make sense of that space?
Jason Blumer: That's a good question, and it's one a lot of founders wrestle with. Ian, I know you'll have a lot to say too, because Karbon has gone through iterations. I think it starts with feeling different. Something's off. The things I used to do produced the leads I needed to grow, and that hasn't happened for a year and a half now. What's going on? But these businesses are very human-centric, so the founder typically goes first to, what am I doing wrong? That can keep going: I'm not the right person for this, I'm bad at hiring, I never should have done this. They go down a really dangerous road, which is why we wanted to inject some hope into the book. None of that's true. The structure and the system aren't working at the size you're at now.
So they feel it first. They wonder what's going on, and there's a lot they can't put their finger on. They start saying, I don't know what's going on with that client anymore, because a manager knows more about it than I do. That feels really weird. A lot of questions come up that they can't answer. It's different for every firm. These firms are so intimate; we say they're reflections of the owner, so they're all very different, and you can't compare your firm to another. But you start to feel it. If you have a coach or consultant in your life, you can work it out with them and say, I think this is it. Your structure supports a team of five to eight, and you're at 12 to 15. The structure doesn't support 12 to 15, so we need a new layer of leadership, and some promotions need to happen. They ask, who do I promote? Then you work through the hiring, the promotion, and the call to leadership for that person. How are you going to start leading another leader? That's a whole other skill. Leading yourself is one problem. Leading other leaders, which you mentioned, Scott, is another.
So you feel it first, and it probably goes on for a while, maybe a year or a year and a half, where you keep trying what you've always known to do and something keeps not working. Instead of going down the road of, I'm a bad founder, we say, don't go that way. It's probably a structural issue that hasn't been intentionally changed at the right time. I will say this, and Ian, you may feel this too, though I've never asked you: we've both gone through these in our companies, where we say, wow, this isn't working anymore. Once you've gone through two or three, you start to notice them. You have some experience, and you think, I believe I have to reboot the senior level now, because that's not working anymore. You get a better feel for it over time, so it stops scaring you as much. You think, okay, now I have to redo this thing. We call it a restructure: I have to restructure my department or my senior layer. So you do start to notice it over time. Ian, have you noticed yours when Karbon has gone through significant changes?
Ian Vacin: Yeah, it's more chaotic than when you're smaller. When you're larger, over 100 or 200 people, you usually have a department structure that starts to fall apart. Usually you see people leaving the firm in that area, or ultimately you have to push the leader out. As soon as you're doing that, you're already doing org design. Having gone through it enough times in my career, we do annual planning, but we also do horizon planning and organizational design, looking at what things look like this year, next year, and so forth. So to Scott's point, it's all about the organization.
To add on to what Jason said, the reason I got into writing the book was that we've done research for eight years, and when we looked at revenue per employee across firm sizes, we didn't see a linear answer. It was very dippy. There were two prominent curves for professional service-based businesses, which I wouldn't necessarily have expected. When we dug into the details, it all came down to human capital, which is why the book is all about team dynamics. As team sizes grow and the scaffolding doesn't exist, you get a compression that shows up in indicators like revenue per employee.
So, to your question about how you know you're going through one of these: what Jason said is true. When you start to feel it, that's an indicator. But you can also get a good understanding of when to expect it, so you can plan intentionally beforehand. That's why we talk about these plateaus. One exists between eight and 20 people. The range is broad because it depends on how much technical work your teams do, which determines how much time the manager or owner has to invest in making sure those technical deliverables get done. If the work isn't as technical, your span of control can be a lot higher, up to about 12 people. If it's very technical, it needs to come down to about six. When you see that human behavior and organization design playing out fully in the data, it's crazy. You think, all that stuff I learned about and have seen and felt, I can actually see it. That was one of the fun, nerdy things about the book.
Scott Allen: What you're touching on here is so important, because I think there's also an identity shift, and a new set of skills is required. When we decide to scale, it's often just, hey, let's grow. And we don't always, back to that word, think intentionally about the ramifications. Especially when I'm working with engineers, CPAs, surgeons, and pilots, people who are used to rules, concrete checklists, policies, procedures, and steps. At this level, there are very few policies and procedures. It just gets more and more gray, and that's uncomfortable. Existing in the gray doesn't feel normal. I imagine it's a very tough transition from a skill-set standpoint and from an identity standpoint.
Jason Blumer: Yeah, and I talk about that in the book. I went through that identity issue, Scott. Julie, my partner, got pretty direct with me about that quote Ian mentioned. When you're a founder, it's a particular thing, because the company was typically created out of your mind. You're the owner, and you're also the one who founded it. So you have a real affinity and emotional attachment to your company. Then there's a point, a particular size, at which the company outpaces who you are. For a founder, the company and me are very similar. But if the company keeps growing, it starts to become its own entity, and you become simply an employee: the CEO. Now you have a job description and a salary, just like every other employee. That's where you may still act like a founder and say, well, I don't want to do it that way. And the answer is, we're not asking whether you want to do it that way anymore. The company demands this at its size. So you have to change your identity and say, I can't run this company as an extension of myself.
Some of the worst places we get into come from treating the company bank account like our personal bank account, which is what I did. That backfires really hard when you start getting into debt, lowering your salary, and talking to your wife about it. That's not fun. Your identity change is forced on you. Sometimes you're at the kitchen table going through it, and then you see your therapist for a while afterward. Identity changes can be pretty brutal, but they have to happen, because at some point the company becomes its own entity. It has needs: for structure, for a certain amount of revenue at a certain volume and pace. It doesn't get to be your preference anymore, even though you founded it. That's true in technical firms, and in technology firms it's a huge deal. We hear stories where founders are removed, and I think that's a known thing in Silicon Valley.
Ian Vacin: In business, hopefully you're building something that outlasts you. But you always have to evaluate where the seat on the bus is, for everybody in the firm and also for yourself, and how that changes as the firm matures. I'm not the CEO of our firm. I hired a CEO, and she runs it a million times better than I ever would. I'm still a co-founder, but I had to let go of that. You have to understand your boundaries. Leadership is about understanding what you can and can't do. If you want to run the most successful business, you want to build one where you aren't the smartest person at the table. That means giving up control, and you may find at some point that you're not in the business because you're not the right fit for it. And that's okay. But you have to understand at the beginning, when you go down these pathways, what you're prepared to do.
Scott Allen: Yeah. There's a lot of self-awareness required. Ian, I have great respect for that decision, because it's also about where your energy is. Back to some of our earlier statements, a CPA's energy may not be in leading people all day, or in business development, or fill in the blank. And that's what the job becomes. So there's a skill difference, an energy difference, and an identity difference. It's so incredibly complex. Well, as we begin to wind down, because we've been going for about 33 minutes, what's the practical wisdom for listeners on scaling with purpose? Jason, maybe we start with you.
Jason Blumer: The first parts of the book are a call to the entrepreneur to start running the business with intention, and it comes back to that quote: do you want what it means? Ian created a matrix early in the book that helps people grade themselves. Is that chapter one, Ian?
Ian Vacin: Chapter one. The entrepreneurial matrix.
Jason Blumer: You have to know if you're ready and if you want what this means. Do you want to grow? You can't just say, I want to grow, and leave it there. That's accidental growth, and it comes back to bite you. The book is about being intentional, with purpose. So, do you want to grow? You don't have to say yes. You can say no, I want to stay where I am. The question is whether you want what growth is going to mean for you, your family, and your identity. It will challenge all of that, and that's okay, because in return you get a really cool business with a lot of great people to lead, and you'll change and grow by being with them. But make sure you're walking a path you want. Ian pushed for a lot of research in this book, so we met with a lot of people, and many of them grew and then shrank on purpose. They accidentally grew, then said nope, and intentionally cut back to the right size. Of course, they all said that was really hard and pretty painful. So we're saying: do you want what it means? Make sure you don't grow to a size that isn't right for you. Ask, is this what I want? Do I want to keep going? You may not. Or if you do, we have a book we think will help you.
Scott Allen: I love it. Okay, Ian.
Ian Vacin: Mine builds on the same thing. We end the book talking about enterprise value: building a business that has value for you, and also the greatest value if someone wanted to buy it. We talked to many firm owners, and the firm size that gives maximum value is different for every single firm. One thing that was shocking: we interviewed well over a couple hundred folks one-on-one to dig into their businesses, and when we really started to dig in, everybody has the voices in their heads. Everybody has the concerns, the nervousness, the fear of possible failure, the weight of the business. If you have those, you're not alone. It feels like you are, but you're not.
A lot of times, like Jason said, you have to go backward to go forward. Ninety-five percent of businesses grew accidentally. Only 5% did it with intention. So if you're in the accidental group, you're not alone, and that's okay. But realize that sometimes the step back is exactly what you need. We talked to many firms, like Jason said, that went from 16 people down to eight, and they love life. They love where they are right now, and they're making more money. Their profit is bigger than ever. So for everybody out there, and Scott, I know you talk about this, take a moment to step back from your business. Get a bottle of wine if that's what it takes, go away for the weekend, and just take time to think. Then reach out to others in your peer network, or listen to more podcasts like this one, and put the recipe together for how you can take action and step forward into whatever is right for you and your business. This book will help you with that as well.
Scott Allen: I love it. Gentlemen, we'll do it again. I really appreciate your time and how you're thinking about this. I appreciate the thoughtfulness, the care, and the help you're giving a lot of people to slow down and pause. Ian, as you said, get that bottle of wine and really think it through: is this what I want my life to be? Is this what I want to build? If so, awesome. But do it with intention, and understand some of what you're going to have to give up and what you're going to have to live into to get there. To the two of you, thank you. Awesome stuff.
Jason Blumer: Awesome stuff. Appreciate it, Scott. Thank you, man.
Scott Allen: Okay, be well.
Thank you so much for listening to Practical Wisdom for Leaders, the official podcast of the International Leadership Association. Be sure to leave a rating, share this episode with someone in your network, and visit the show notes for links, references, and additional resources. You can also subscribe to the Practical Wisdom for Leaders newsletter; the link is in the show notes. I lead retreats for senior leadership teams, conduct engaging workshops, and deliver inspiring keynotes for organizations across industries. To learn more, visit www.scottjallen.net. Until next time, keep changing lives.